European Convention on Human Rights ECHR
- Protocol 12: Discrimination Protocol 12 –
discrimination Main article: Protocol 12 to the European Convention on Human Rights Applies the current expansive and indefinite grounds of prohibited discrimination in Article 14 to the exercise of any legal right and to the actions (including the obligations) of public authorities. The Protocol entered into force on 1 April 2005 and has (as of March 2018) been ratified by 20 member states. Several member states—Bulgaria, Denmark, France, Lithuania, Monaco, Poland, Sweden, Switzerland, and the United Kingdom—have not signed the protocol. The United Kingdom government
has declined to sign
Protocol 12 on the basis that they believe the wording of protocol is too
wide and would result in a flood of new cases testing the extent of the new
provision. They believe that the phrase "rights set forth by law"
might include international conventions to which the UK is not a party and
would result in incorporation of these instruments by stealth. It has been
suggested that the protocol is therefore in a catch-22, since the UK will decline to either sign or
ratify the protocol until the European
Court of Human Rights has addressed the meaning of the provision, while the court is
hindered in doing so by the lack of applications to the court concerning the
protocol caused by the decisions of Europe's most populous states—including
the UK—not to ratify the protocol. The UK government, nevertheless, stated in
2004 that it "agrees in principle that the ECHR should contain a provision
against discrimination that is free-standing and not parasitic on the other
Convention rights". The first judgment that found a violation
of Protocol No. 12, Sejdić and Finci v. Bosnia and Herzegovina,
was delivered in 2009. |